Angkor Wat, Cambodia
Thursday, October 13, 2011
Coherence Principle
There are several key principles found in e-learning. One of the primary principles is called the Coherence Principle. The Coherence Principle states that "all non-essential information in multimedia messages should be elininated ti minimise demands on cognitive resources" (Muller, Lee & Sharma, 2008, p 2111) One thing that many do not realize is, the dropout rate for e-learners is very high. There are estimats that the dropout rate for r-learners is 20 - 50 %, while other schools report that the drop out rae for e-learners is 10 - 20 percentage points higher than students who attend traditional classes. Because of this high dropout rate many instructors have tried to make their presenations more alluring or interesting by placing background music in their power point presntations. But research has proven this is a huge mistake. The advice of Clark & Meyer, 2011, is "don't do it". Learning is much deeper when there is no audio, i.e. sounds and music, are eliminated from e-learning (actually, learning in general). The difference is quite dramatic. In one study students were tested on how much they learned while listening to music and how much they learned without sounds and music. Students who did not have background noise such as music, outperformed students who had background noise by a range 61% - 141%. Another study compared quality of writing. Researchers looked at the quality of essays by students who listened to music versus students who had not listened to music. Although the quality of the essays was simliar, it took students who listened to music considerably longer to write the same quality essay as students in a quiet environment. In conclusion, in an e-learning environment leave the background noise out of your presentations. Soft background music may sound pleasant but only hurts the learning process. The same is true of all background sounds.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This is very interesting, I never thought that the drop out rate would be higher when it came to e-learning classes than traditional classes. As I thought about it a little, I can see why students are dropping out of e-learning classes because students can get lazy and forgetful of the assignments they have to do online. Also they might feel that an online class is boring and not effective so they might just decide to drop the class and find a traditional style course to take. There are those who are able to study with music and do well on their assignments and there are those who cannot study with music or any other type of sounds around them because they feel it is a distraction. When it comes to my preference, it varies because it depends on the assignments I am working on. If the assignment requires all my attention, I will not work on the assignment with the TV or music going (i.e. reading a textbook, studying, writing an essay). But there are times when I am working on powerpoint presentations, which I love to make, I can listen to my music or watch TV as I am creating it.
ReplyDeleteI'm a little surprised by this, particularly because so many students have headphones on and listen to music while they do their homework, use their computer, etc. As for the dropout rate, I wonder if part of it is due to an anonymity factor, i.e. one feels less accountable when he/she can't actually see the teacher or actively discuss things with the teacher...kind of like exercising on your own (cough cough ) as opposed to going to an exercise class where there's more pressure to give it your all.
ReplyDeleteit seems that the online learners have less patience on keep their learrning going on, this is a very interesting phenomenon!
ReplyDelete